The Future of Manufacturing:

Balancing National Interests and Global Trade

 

In today's interconnected world, outsourcing is an inevitable reality. While it’s often seen as negatively impacting our national interests or economic health, it’s important to recognize that not all outsourcing is detrimental. The question we must address is: which resources, products, and industries are vital to our national security and economic well-being, and which can be sourced from the global market?

​

Critical Sectors That Should Remain Domestic

​

In today’s globalized world, some industries and resources are too crucial to our national security and economic stability, and well-being to be left in the hands of foreign suppliers. Keeping key sectors within the U.S. ensures that we can respond to crises, maintain technological leadership, and protect our infrastructure.

 

This list, though not exhaustive, highlights some of the industries and resources that are crucial for maintaining national security and economic stability. However, it is important to note that the majority of goods and services we rely on in modern society do not fall into these categories and can often be more cost effectively be produced abroad.

​

1. Automobile Manufacturing

The automobile industry is essential not only for transportation but also for national security. Domestic production of vehicles — including cars, trucks, military vehicles, and emerging technologies like electric and autonomous systems ensures that we maintain control over critical infrastructure and can respond swiftly in times of crisis.

​

Just as importantly, automobile manufacturing supports hundreds of thousands of high-paying jobs across the country, not only on factory floors, but in engineering, design, logistics, and skilled trades. These jobs are a cornerstone of the American middle class and help sustain regional economies.

​

Keeping this industry domestic also helps preserve technical expertise, from precision machining to advanced robotics, and ensures that future generations have access to meaningful, well-paying careers in manufacturing and innovation.

​

2. Critical Infrastructure Components

Components like transformers and power grid systems are vital to our daily lives. By producing these domestically, we reduce dependency on foreign suppliers and protect our electrical grid from disruptions, including cyberattacks or natural disasters.

​​

3. Artificial Intelligence, Robotics & Advanced Automation

Automation is revolutionizing industries, boosting productivity from manufacturing to defense sectors. By maintaining control over AI systems, robotic technologies, and advanced manufacturing equipment, we can ensure these advancements align with our needs, both in civilian life and military context.

​

4. Pharmaceuticals & Medical Equipment

The pandemic revealed how vulnerable our pharmaceutical supply chains can be. To safeguard public health, the U.S. must produce critical medicines at home, ensuring availability during emergencies. Similarly, from diagnostic machines to advanced surgical instruments, medical technology is essential for public health. Manufacturing critical medical devices domestically ensures a steady supply during crises like pandemics and natural disasters.

​​

5. Engineering Materials

Strategic materials such as rare earth elements form the foundation of our modern society and defense systems. Securing a reliable domestic supply of these materials is essential to avoid dependence on foreign sources and mitigate geopolitical risks.

 

6. Integrated Circuits

Microprocessors and integrated circuits are integral to everything from consumer electronics to military equipment. By ensuring the domestic production of chips, the U.S. can maintain control over critical technologies and safeguard against potential disruptions caused by global shortages.

​

7. Fossil Energy Resources

While renewable energy is growing, fossil fuels remain the dominant and primary energy source powering the vast majority of our economy. By maintaining domestic production of fossil fuels, the U.S. ensures energy security and supports key industries that rely on these resources.

​

8. Aerospace & Defense Technologies

The aerospace industry, which includes aircraft, satellites, and military defense systems, is critical for both national security and global competitiveness. Maintaining domestic production ensures that we have the technological edge in both civilian space exploration and military defense.

​

9. Cybersecurity & Data Infrastructure

As cyber threats grow more sophisticated, ensuring domestic control over cybersecurity infrastructure becomes essential. Protecting critical data, government systems, and private industry against cyberattacks ensures national security and economic stability.

​

10. Food & Agricultural Technology

Ensuring domestic control over food production and agricultural technology is crucial for national food security. Keeping food production within the U.S. guarantees a stable, resilient supply of food and allows the country to effectively respond to natural disasters, economic disruptions, or supply chain issues. Maintaining control over agricultural processes ensures that the U.S. can safeguard its food sources and protect public health in times of crisis.

​​​​

The Strategic Benefits of Outsourcing

​

Outsourcing production for many products that are not critical to our national well-being and security can offer numerous advantages, particularly in industries where manufacturing costs are driven by low-cost labor and economies of scale.

​

Outsourcing these products helps keep consumer prices low and ensures that businesses remain competitive. If we tried to bring all these manufacturing jobs back to the U.S., we would face significant challenges in terms of labor costs, technological readiness, and overall economic impact.​

​​

Recognizing the Balance: National Interest vs. Globalization

​

The key challenge we face is recognizing which industries and resources should remain domestic and which can be more effectively outsourced. For some industries, like those vital to national defense and critical infrastructure, domestic production should be non-negotiable. For others, especially those that are low-cost and low technology, outsourcing offers some clear benefits.

​

It is also equally crucial for our national well-being that for components, products, and technologies that are deemed to not be critical that we allow American companies to have the autonomy to make decisions that are best for their business, allowing them to successfully compete in a globalized economy. This flexibility fosters growth not only for the companies themselves but also for our broader economy as well. Ultimately, embracing a competitive, global market helps drive innovation and strengthens the nation's economic foundation.

​​

The Reality of Bringing All Jobs Back: Challenges and Considerations

​

While there’s a push to bring manufacturing jobs back to the United States, this effort comes with significant hurdles:

​

1. Low-Cost, Low-Technology Products
Many outsourced products are basic, low-cost items produced using simple manufacturing methods, essentially, they are commodities. For instance, components for products like my LED electronic flags are inexpensive and low-tech. Manufacturing these domestically would significantly increase costs and leave little room for profit. In such fiercely competitive global markets, U.S. companies attempting to produce these items locally would likely face serious challenges staying competitive or even solvent.

​

2. Employee Satisfaction and Job Appeal
Assembly jobs, especially those in low-tech manufacturing, are often repetitive and physically demanding. Without high wages and good benefits, these positions are less attractive to many workers. While bringing jobs back could create employment opportunities, many of these roles would offer lower pay and fewer benefits compared to higher-skilled positions in advanced manufacturing.

​

3. The Globalized World Has Evolved
Technology and the world economy have changed dramatically over the past few decades. Attempting to revert to past manufacturing practices could slow our progress and leave us at a disadvantage. Instead of focusing on bringing low-tech jobs back, we should embrace modern manufacturing methods, automation, and innovation to remain competitive on a global scale.

​

4. Global Competitive Advantage
In today’s capitalist economy, companies are constantly seeking ways to reduce costs and maximize profits. By moving manufacturing to countries with lower labor costs, U.S. companies have been able to remain competitive. If we were to insist on bringing all manufacturing jobs back, we would risk diminishing the competitiveness of American companies, which could lead to reduced profits, and potentially, business closures.

​

5. Skilled Workforce Shortage
Bringing manufacturing jobs back to the U.S. requires a skilled workforce. Unfortunately, we face a shortage of engineers, technicians, and assembly workers in many sectors. Rebuilding the workforce and training a new generation of skilled workers would take significant time and resources, and many of these jobs may soon be replaced by automation and robotics anyway.

​

6. Price Inflation and Economic Impact
If we were to bring all manufacturing back to the U.S., the cost of everyday goods could skyrocket due to higher labor costs. This would likely lead to inflation, and the resulting economic turmoil could harm U.S. businesses and consumers alike.

​

7. Economic Isolationism
An overemphasis on bringing all manufacturing back could lead to isolationist policies that would limit the U.S.'s access to global markets and partnerships. In the long run, this could harm our economy and reduce our ability to compete internationally.

 

​​Embrace Strategic Manufacturing and Global Competitiveness

​

While there are certain industries and resources that are vital to our national security and economic stability, we must recognize the broader context of global trade. Outsourcing manufacturing for many products provides clear benefits, including lower costs and greater global competitiveness. Instead of trying to turn back the clock, we should focus on strategic investments in high-tech, advanced manufacturing and foster innovation to maintain our global leadership.

​

By embracing modern manufacturing practices and leveraging global resources where appropriate, we can ensure that the U.S. remains competitive and resilient in the face of an ever-evolving global economy.